Three reviews, three failures: Shubman Gill’s DRS horror show against New Zealand

Three reviews, three failures: Shubman Gill’s DRS horror show against New Zealand


India captain Shubman Gill’s desperation to break New Zealand’s resistance came at a cost on the opening two days of the first Test at the Basin Reserve in Wellington. Gill was involved in each of the three unsuccessful reviews across the opening two days, while his decision not to review a clear edge off Anshul Kamboj’s bowling against Rachin Ravindra on Day 1 added to India’s frustration.

India vs New Zealand 1st Test Day 2: UPDATES | SCORECARD

Gill’s record as India’s Test captain had already raised questions about his use of DRS. Figures reported in August 2026 showed that he had taken 41 reviews, of which only five had been successful, while the other 36 had gone against India. The three unsuccessful reviews in Wellington have added to that tally.

GILL’S FIRST REVIEW GOES AGAINST INDIA

India’s first review came on Day 1 when Jasprit Bumrah bowled a delivery that moved back towards Glenn Phillips and beat his bat. The Indian players appealed for LBW, but umpire Richard Illingworth turned it down.

Bumrah was not convinced that the ball was hitting the stumps and told Gill, “height hai” (it’s high). Gill, however, believed there had been no contact with the bat and decided to take the review.

The Snickometer showed a spike as the ball passed the bat. However, the front-on replay did not make the contact clear, prompting third umpire Paul Reiffel to take another look in slow motion. He eventually ruled that there had been a slight deflection, and the on-field decision of not out stood.

Gill was unhappy with the outcome and tried to explain his reading of the incident to Illingworth. He believed there was a gap between bat and ball and that the delivery had hit Phillips’ back pad first. India had lost their first review.

GILL IGNORES PANT’S DRS CALL

India also missed a clear caught-behind dismissal off Anshul Kamboj’s bowling against Rachin Ravindra on Day 1. Bowling with the new ball at the Basin Reserve, Kamboj induced an outside edge from the New Zealand batter, which was cleanly taken by wicketkeeper Rishabh Pant.

However, the on-field umpire turned down India’s appeal. Pant and the slip fielders urged Gill to challenge the decision, but the India captain decided against sending it upstairs before the review timer ran out.

Subsequent UltraEdge replays confirmed a clear spike as the ball passed the bat, suggesting that a review would have overturned the decision.

Ravindra survived the early scare and went on to face 50 deliveries before eventually being dismissed caught behind off Akash Deep. Kamboj had already made an impact with the new ball, dismissing Devon Conway early as New Zealand slipped to 12/2.

INDIA WASTE TWO REVIEWS ON DAY 2

Day 2 brought two more unsuccessful reviews, both involving Akash Deep. The first came when the pacer trapped Nathan Smith on the pads with a delivery that nipped back sharply. India appealed for LBW, but umpire Kumar Dharmasena was not convinced.

Akash Deep had concerns that the ball might have been too high, but Gill decided to review the decision. Ball-tracking showed that the delivery was going over the stumps. India had now used two reviews, with only one left.

The final review came when Akash Deep bowled a short delivery to Matt Henry. The New Zealand batter moved away from the line and did well to keep his hands clear of the ball. Akash Deep did not appeal initially, while wicketkeeper Rishabh Pant also showed little interest.

Gill, standing at first slip, was convinced there had been an edge and immediately opted for a review. However, the replays showed a clear gap between bat and ball. The Snickometer also showed a flat line, leaving little doubt that Henry had not edged it.

Gill could only manage a sheepish smile as India lost their final review. Henry was smiling too.

There was another LBW appeal against Kyle Jamieson later in the innings, but India chose not to review it. Prasidh Krishna had beaten the batter with a sharp delivery that nipped back, but the ball was going over the stumps. This time, India made the right call.

NICHOLLS, PHILLIPS PUNISH INDIA

India’s review troubles came despite a promising start with the ball. They had reduced New Zealand to 70/5, but Henry Nicholls and Glenn Phillips put together a partnership of more than 200 runs to turn the innings around.

Phillips scored 118 before Akash Deep finally broke the stand on Day 2. The pacer had tried going wide of the crease several times before coming closer to the stumps and producing the delivery that beat Phillips’ outside edge.

Nicholls, however, continued to frustrate the Indian attack and remained unbeaten on 175 as New Zealand were bowled out for 368 in 121 overs.

India took the remaining four wickets for just 51 runs after lunch. Bumrah finished with four wickets for 92 runs, while Akash Deep picked up three for 53. Prasidh Krishna also claimed a wicket, with Kamboj taking the final one.

Nicholls received a standing ovation from the Basin Reserve crowd as he walked off the field. Gill went up to shake his hand, while the New Zealand batter’s family led the applause.

– Ends



Source link
[ad_3]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *