‘Islamabad, Not IWT To Blame’: 25 Pakistan Voices Say Water Crisis Is Homegrown, Not India’s Doing

‘Islamabad, Not IWT To Blame’: 25 Pakistan Voices Say Water Crisis Is Homegrown, Not India’s Doing


News world ‘Islamabad, Not IWT To Blame’: 25 Pakistan Voices Say Water Crisis Is Homegrown, Not India’s Doing

Last Updated:

CNN-News18 went through 25 articles by Pakistani writers, published between 2017 and October 2026

India temporarily suspended its participation in the 1960 Indus Waters Treaty (IWT) on April 23, 2025, placing the agreement in abeyance. (File)

India temporarily suspended its participation in the 1960 Indus Waters Treaty (IWT) on April 23, 2025, placing the agreement in abeyance. (File)

Former ministers, hydrologists and a retired PAF officer say waste, neglect and fights between provinces, not the Indus Waters Treaty (IWT) abeyance, are draining Pakistan dry.

Ever since India put the Indus Waters Treaty in abeyanceIslamabad has stuck to one line: New Delhi is choking Pakistan’s water. Pakistan’s own experts tell a very different story.

CNN-News18 went through 25 articles by Pakistani writers, published between 2017 and October 2026. The authors include former ministers, a former ambassador, hydrologists and a retired Pakistan Air Force officer. Their pieces ran in Dawn, The Express Tribune, The News, The Friday Times and Business Recorder. Almost all of them come to the same conclusion: Pakistan’s water crisis was made at home.

“No. We did that ourselves,” wrote retired Group Captain S.M. Hali in Business Recorder. He was asking whether India had told Pakistan to build housing on floodplains, skip building dams or cut down its forests.

Farming takes almost everything

The numbers come from Pakistan’s own experts. Water-sector professional Dr Imran Aziz Tunio writes that agriculture uses more than 90% of the country’s fresh waterwhile irrigation efficiency is below 40%.

Nearly half of the water released at canal heads leaks away before it reaches a farm, according to former Punjab Irrigation Minister Mohsin Leghari. Writing in Dawn, Naseer Memon says that of 143 billion cubic metres (BCM) available at canal headsonly 55 BCM is put to good use on crops.

At A Glance

  • 1.

    Agriculture consumes more than 90 percent of Pakistan’s fresh water while the country’s irrigation efficiency remains below 40 percent.

  • 2.

    Four major crops including rice, wheat, sugarcane, and cotton utilize over 80 percent of the water supply while contributing only 5 percent to the GDP.

  • 3.

    Pakistan has lacked a full-time Indus Waters Commissioner since January 2018 and the National Water Council has not convened since October 2018.

  • Four crops, rice, wheat, sugarcane and cotton, use more than 80% of Pakistan’s water. Together they add just 5% to GDP.

    Empty posts, a council that stopped meeting

    Leghari also points to gaps at the top. Pakistan has had no full-time Indus Waters Commissioner since January 2018, even though the post was created by the treaty itself. There is no dedicated Federal Secretary for Water Resources. The National Water Council has not met since October 2018.

    “Pakistan cannot demand transparency from others while tolerating opacity at home,” Leghari wrote.

    Full dams, dry Sindh

    A June 2026 river bulletin, analysed in The Friday Times, showed Kotri Barrage in Sindh with zero discharge downstream. At the same time, Tarbela was still storing water and link canals were diverting water upstream. The writer’s conclusion was blunt: “Water is available in the system.” The real fault line, he argued, runs between Punjab and Sindh.

    Underground, the picture is just as grim. Tube-wells pump without regulation, and water tables are falling across Punjab and Sindh.

    Not a shortage, a misuse problem

    Some experts reject the idea of scarcity altogether. Hydrologist Dr Hassan Abbas wrote in 2018 that Pakistan needs less than 77 million acre-feet (MAF) of water a year for domestic, industrial and food needs, while its rivers bring in about 145 MAF. “We are neither water deficient nor water scarce,” he wrote.

    A ‘multiplier’, not the cause

    Several writers do criticise India’s decision, but they still turn the question back on Islamabad. In Business Recorder, Fazeel Asif called the treaty’s suspension “a multiplier,” not a substitute for internal reform. He concluded that the system “is not dying of thirst; it is dying of avoidance.”

    Years before the abeyance, former World Bank adviser Abid Hasan had already called blaming India for Pakistan’s water problems “a convenient alibi.”

    The verdict from Pakistan’s own experts is clear. Leaking canals, unregulated tube-wells, empty posts and fights between provinces were all there long before New Delhi acted.

    About the Author

    Siddhant Mishra

    Siddhant Mishra

    Siddhant Mishra is a Senior Special Correspondent at CNN-News18, covering foreign affairs and international relations. With over 12 years of experience in journalism, he has also reported extensively …Read More

    Disclaimer: Comments reflect users’ views, not News18’s. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

    Read More



    Source link
    [ad_3]

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *